Time to cut the carrots

Grow Your Own Media

Posted April 23, 2019
Share To

In 1879, the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzche began to go blind.

The growing blindness curtailed his writing and as such, compounded his already growing depression.

In a way that we would all understand, he sought out a technological fix. He ordered a Danish made Malling-Hansen Writing Ball.  It was the first manufactured typewriter ever made and sold.

Today, we would probably not recognize it as a typewriter. It was a sold ball of keys. To type on it, you embraced the ball with both hands and typed out the letters.  But it worked.  

Malling-Hansen Typewriter

For Nietzsche, it was a God-send.  Soon he was typing 800 characters a minute with his eyes blissfully closed.

However, Nietzsche soon discovered that the machine was warping not just his style of writing, but also the way in which he thought.  His sentences became shorter, more to the point; his ideas more condensed.  He said that the 'iron' of the machine was now transferred into the words he was creating.1 

In time, he gave up on the typewriter and instead dictated his work to secretaries.

His friend Koselitz the composer noted that in his own work. his 'thoughts in music and language often depended on the quality of the pen and the paper.'

"You are right", Nietzsche responded. "Our writing equipment takes part in the forming of our thoughts."

If the mechanical typewriter warped Nietzsche's thinking and writing, one can only imagine the impact that trying to express an idea in video has, both on the maker of the content and the viewer.  It is fair to say that our technology often defines not just how we communicate but also what it is we communicate.

"We shape our tools," John Culkin, Jesuit Priest, and media scholar wrote in 1967, "and thereafter they shape us".

Today, our primary tool of communication is video. According to Cisco, 85% of all Internet traffic this year is going to be video. Video is the dominant form of online, and hence increasingly, all communication. 

But, as Marshall McLuhan noted in his seminal work, Understanding Media, our tools end up numbing whatever part of the body they also amplify. When we were farmers (which almost all of us were until very recently), we had a direct and organic and very personal connection with the soil and with crops. 

When farming become industrialized, we lost that connection forever.  Today, only 3% of the population works in agriculture. No farmer in their right mind would ever eat a bag of Pringles or Doritos. Anyone who grows crops with their hands has a deep and organic understanding of what is food. But take away that intense personal relationship with the soil and with planting and growing and you soon have a population that can no longer differentiate between a carrot and a Twinkie. That loss of a direct connection to growing food and the soil made us obese. 

As the industrialization of agriculture separated us from the soil and from an innate knowledge of what was good food vs. bad; so too has the industrialization of media separated us from an innate knowledge of what is real news and what is news that is as fake and packaged as a bag of Doritos - and as unhealthy.

Nietzsche abandoned the typewriter because he felt it distanced him from the organic feel of writing. The organic food movement tries to reconnect us with that intimate relationship to the soil and hence to what we eat and our basic physical health.

Until now, we have been unable to have an organic relationship to our media because it was too mechanized, too complex and too expensive. You could not 'grow your own news'. 

This is no longer the case.

Your smartphone or your iPhone can empower you to connect or reconnect to a far more simple and basic 'truth' in media.  


Like growing raspberries or tomatoes in your back yard, you can grow your own media, and in doing so, attain a different relationship not just to what you make or can make, but also to what the industrial world is feeding you.

It is different.

"Alienation," McLuhan wrote, "is an inevitable by-product of the use of technology."

It does not have to be that way.

If you can grow your own vegetables and reconnect with real food and thus empower yourself to free yourself from a life of Twinkies, so too can you empower yourself and learn to grow your own media.

Organic food

Organic media

Pick up your phone

Plant some seeds

Take control of what you put into your mind as you would take control of what you put into your mouth and body.  


1 Thanks to Nicholas Carr, who tells this story far better in his wonderful book, The Shallows


Recent Posts

For most of human history, people lived in a world without news. The concept simply did not exist. The idea of news is really a 19th-century phenomenon, driven first by newspapers, and then by electronic media which brought us radio, then TV and now the web. Now, it seems, we are headed back to a world without news. Not because the technology is not there, but rather because, increasingly, people are no longer interested in news, at least in the way it is packaged now.

What TV News Could Be
February 26, 2024

When television was invented in the 1930s, no one knew what TV news was supposed to look like. The medium had never existed before, and so, like Gutenberg half a millennium, prior, the first creators of TV news had to fall back on a medium with which they were familiar, and that was radio.

Maybe scary stories drive ratings… or maybe they don’t.

Share Page on: